GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AMERICA                                                BOOK    MANUSCRIPT
                            P.O. Box 9140, Boulder, CO 80301                                            REVIEWER'S APPRAISAL  FORM

              Author(s):
              Title:
              Pleme indimte the strength of your response by marking the @le betwwn YES and NO.  Marginal notm may be made on the manmript where appropriate, UN
              additional shmts m n@ary to answer quotions 1- 17.  Pleme send two wpi@ of any additional mmments.

              1. Dom this paper wotain new and original principle or wnwpts?................................................                                     Ym                             No
                                   dmribe a geologi@lly important area in an original way?.........................................                              Ym                             No
                                   wnstitute  a  meful   review?..................................................................                               Y@                             No
                                   repon  signifi@nt  new  data?................................................................                                 Ym                             No
              2.  Are the data available sufficient to jmtify the interpretations and wnclwions?.......................................                          Y@                             No
              3.  Are fwts clearly separated from interpretations?..............................................................                                 Ym                             No
              4.  Is the paper well organized?.............................................................................                                      YM                             No
              5.  Is the paper cl@rly written?.............................................................................                                      ym                             No
              6.  Ho any part of this paper bmn published previowly, or is it part of another manmript?
                         If ya, plme explain:

              7.  Would this paper be of intermt in more than one subdiwipline of the g@ienm?
                         Pl@ list:

              8.  Can you suggmt any remonable way(s) to shorten the paper?
                         Pl@  s@ify:

              9.  Can you sugg@t any improvemen@s) in the dde and/or abstract?
                         Pl@ spmify:

              10. Can parts of the text be replaced by figurm and/or summary tablm?
                         Pl@ sf=ify:

              11. Cm my of the illwtratims be reduced in size, wmbined, eliminated, or signiflandy improved?
                         Pime specify:

              12, Are any additional illustrations needed?
                         Pleme specify:

              13. Is the use of mathemti@ appropriate and wrrmt?

              14. How do you rate this manuxript? (circle one)           Excellent         Very good          Good          Fair            Pwr

              15, If this paper ranks low, wuld it be made into a topqwlity paper?
                         If so, how?

              16. On  the  bois  of  your  review  r@rded  above,  should  this  paper  be  published  by  GSA  following  any  n@y   revision?

              17, How much revision is requirecr?  (circle  one)       None          slight        Moderate          Mador

              18, Add any other wmments on additional shmt(s).  Pl@ wmment if you r@mmend rejection.
              I agree to be identified to the author(s). (circle one)     Ym          No
              ..............................................................................................                                  I.....................................

              SIGNED:                                                                                       DATE

              Nameand
              address





              NOTE: Th@e forms do not require mrbon paper.  Please use ballpoint  pen  or  typewriter  with  firm  prmure.  Reviewers  should  kmp  bottom  wpy  and  forward  the  top  wpy  to  the
                         editor who sent you the manmript for review.